The Good Doctor Wiki
The Good Doctor Wiki

"One Heart" is the sixth episode of Season 5 of The Good Doctor. It is the eighty-second episode overall and aired on November 15, 2021.


Dr. Shaun Murphy and Dr. Alex Park must grapple with a life-and-death decision and decide between saving one patient over another. Meanwhile, Dr. Morgan Reznick goes a little too far in her attempt to win Salen’s favor.


The Good Doctor’s episode begins with Aaron playing baseball and Lea shows up to tell him that Shaun is struggling right now. She asks him if he is running away, he says no, he is fine and they are fine, go home. Meanwhile, Shaun tells Alex that Lea is gone until Sunday so Alex invites him to a movie and pizza. Asher wheels a man in that fell 30 feet off a scaffolding platform, the man goes into respiratory failure as they try to access his injuries.

Morgan goes to see Salen, she tells her that she can make the clinic profitable, and she wants to close the deal, be in control of the clinic and its budget. Salen tells her to do it, she wants to see what she can do.

Alex and Shaun are looking at their patient’s x-ray, Asher says his pressure is falling. Alex asks if the man is an organ donor, Shaun says it is not relevant, he is not going to let him die.

Alex calls a patient’s mother, Val, he tells her that they have a patient in the OR that is O negative, the heart might fight Ollie, so he wants her to bring him in. She says they are just about to leave for Ollie’s Make A Wish trip, she asks him what she should do, he says to bring him in.

Asher speaks to his patient Brandon’s father, Thomas, before surgery, this is the patient who fell. He wants to speak to his son, but he has been unconscious since the fall.

Morgan does an eye test on a patient, she tells her that she has deficits in her peripheral view, according to the test she is going blind.

Shaun is in surgery, Asher and Audrey are there as well and they are operating on Brandon.

Salen is eating lunch with Marcus, she is eating crickets taco, she tells him they are high in protein. Marcus reluctantly takes a bite. They talk about problems in the hospital.

Aaron is at a bar ax-throwing with his friends when Lea walks in and he asks her when she is going to stop stalking him. She tells him that she omitted some of his negative scores so his customer feedback scores would go up because he was unhappy about his scores. He tells her it is her mess, her responsibility, to go home and clean it up.

Brandon’s bleeding has stopped, but he is in a coma. Asher goes to speak to Thomas to give him some news on Brandon. He tells him that his son is in a common, they are trying to relieve the pressure on his skull so his brain will recover. Given the extent of his injuries, it probably won’t recover and will progress to brain death. Thomas says he was going to call him this week so they could work through some stuff, they haven’t spoken in two years.

Thomas tells him that his father must be very proud of him, Asher says his father wanted a straight rabbi, he failed at both. Thomas just wants to speak to his son again, Asher promises that he is doing everything he can to make that happen.

Morgan goes to see Salen regarding a proposal that she gave her for the contract, Salen says it is too expensive.

Ollie is back in the hospital with her mother, Alex is there and talking to her when she passes out.

Shaun and Asher are looking for a solution for Brandon, Alex walks in and asks Shaun if he has spoken about organ donation. Shaun gets angry and tells him to go away, or he will report him.

Morgan speaks to her patient, she tells her that she found surgery to remove the tumor from behind her eyes but it will also be able to save 60% of her vision.

In the operating room, Audry talks about organ donorship because she thinks their efforts are futile. Shaun doesn’t want to hear it, his new idea has a 1% chance of saving Brandon. Meanwhile, Alex has to go see Ollie’s mother and tell her there is no heart after all.

Alex is upset with Shaun, he tells Shaun that his hail Mary surgery didn’t save his patient, but it just killed him.

Shaun thinks back to the conversations he had with Aaron and then decides it is time to let go of Brandon. He goes to speak to Thomas and he tells him that they can save his son’s heart, donate it to someone else. Asher tells Thomas to go speak to his son, if something needs to be said, then it needs to be said. Thomas has his last words with his son, says his goodbye. Brandon’s heart is given to Ollie.

Salen gives Morgan Aaron’s office, she tells her that she has earned it.

Marcus pours a glass of tequila for him and Salen, he tells her that worms have more protein than crickets.

Shaun and Asher give Thomas a piece of paper that shows where Brandon’s organs went. There are 63 people who Brandon helped.

Asher goes home and he opens some letters that his father sent him that he had never opened.



Guest Starring


  • Robert Underwood as Jerry
  • Anthony Ames as Colson
  • Denise Stauffer as Cardiologist


  • Rachel Bay Jones, who's vegan in real life, confirmed on Instagram that the Cricket Tacos that Salen and Andrews ate were actually vegan.[1]
  • In "Sons," Asher mentions that the letter from his father that he opened was in fact a good one despite his fears to the contrary.


Promotional Images

BTS Images



  1. Rachel Bay Jones] on Instagram: . November 16, 2021.
Season 1
#1 Burnt Food#2 Mount Rushmore#3 Oliver#4 Pipes#5 Point Three Percent#6 Not Fake#7 22 Steps#8 Apple#9 Intangibles#10 Sacrifice#11 Islands: Part One#12 Islands: Part Two#13 Seven Reasons#14 She#15 Heartfelt#16 Pain#17 Smile#18 More
Season 2
#1 Hello#2 Middle Ground#3 36 Hours#4 Tough Titmouse#5 Carrots#6 Two-Ply (or Not Two-Ply)#7 Hubert#8 Stories#9 Empathy#10 Quarantine#11 Quarantine: Part Two#12 Aftermath#13 Xin#14 Faces#15 Risk and Reward#16 Believe#17 Breakdown#18 Trampoline
Season 3
#1 Disaster#2 Debts#3 Claire#4 Take My Hand#5 First Case, Second Base#6 45-Degree Angle#7 SFAD#8 Moonshot#9 Incomplete#10 Friends and Family#11 Fractured#12 Mutations#13 Sex and Death#14 Influence#15 Unsaid#16 Autopsy#17 Fixation#18 Heartbreak#19 Hurt#20 I Love You
Season 4
#1 Frontline Part One#2 Frontline Part Two#3 Newbies#4 Not the Same#5 Fault#6 Lim#7 The Uncertainty Principle#8 Parenting#9 Irresponsible Salad Bar Practices#10 Decrypt#11 We're All Crazy Sometimes#12 Teeny Blue Eyes#13 Spilled Milk#14 Gender Reveal#15 Waiting#16 Dr. Ted#17 Letting Go#18 Forgive or Forget#19 Venga#20 Vamos
Season 5
#1 New Beginnings#2 Piece of Cake#3 Measure of Intelligence#4 Rationality#5 Crazytown#6 One Heart#7 Expired#8 Rebellion#9 Yippee Ki-Yay#10 Cheat Day#11 The Family#12 Dry Spell#13 Growing Pains#14 Potluck#15 My Way#16 The Shaun Show#17 The Lea Show#18 Sons